hold up, am i missing the point??
Gear ratio as you say dictates the turns of rear wheel relative to size of freewheel being used and cog at either end. Wether you have a 22 tooth cog pulling an 18tooth freewheel (approx 1.2 turns of wheel for one rev of crank) with 72 pick ups or the same freewheel to a 12 tooth cog (1.5 rev's as you say) there is still only 72 pick up points in that freewheel, that wont change as its hardware, it is what it is surely?
I was wondering if by having it on the cranks it puts less stress on the pawls as there is no preload through the chain? In my mind, it makes sense to be on the cranks as anyone whos changed one will know their bastards to get off, the principle of using it in whatever application will tighten it using the riders full body weight and strength in their legs as they ride ( is there a splined freewheel and crank set up where the FW fits on the crank similar to a B'guard on the RS7 cranks and then holds it in place with a lock ring,or even on a hub, a big spline with a lock ring like normal cassettes/?? that seems so obvious?????!!!???) so if the bugger gets stuck its a new crank not a new hub/wheel/rebuild so more cost effective, but if on the the freewheel is better protected and the bits facing regular impact are cheap to replace IE a sprocket???? plus if a sprocket is mashed and stuck sticking in a vice and smashing the crank with a rubber mallet or hammer and wood block will save the crank?
I get the idea of balancing the bike and lighter rear end etc, i guess it just depends, that to me is extreme, everything is weighhhhhhh (geddit?) lighter han years ago, we were riding MTB hubs with 7/8 speed blocks and mechs! if you got the money to replace smashed up fw's then fair play, if you haven't i guess protect it on the wheel?
vote guys, in an anoraky sortof way it will be interesting to see what the opinion is and wether people relatively new to the sport, ielast 3-4 years just do it because its whats done. Thinking back now, single speed hubs with fw's would have saved me and my mates loads of money as several fecked the FW and had to get a whole new hub. Say a dmr Revolver and tensile 60 is 60 quid plus rim and build, a hope which was only 36 points back then was something like £150 + rim, build, and gearing!